Member of Parliment,
Mysuru - Kodagu Loksabha Constituency
ಸಂಸದರು,
ಮೈಸೂರು - ಕೊಡಗು ಲೋಕಸಭಾ ಕ್ಷೇತ್ರ
Email : mpmysoresimha@gmail.com
Pratap Simha > Others > Open Letter To Mr. Shah Rukh Khan

Open Letter To Mr. Shah Rukh Khan

http://www.blogs.ivarta.com/Open-letter-Mr-Shahrukh-Khan-SRK/blog-348.htm

Dear Mr. Khan, Your name is a household phenomenon in Indian and even beyond her borders. Your fame has put you in the Newsweek “most powerful people list” recently. However,

as you may recall from your recent experience in New Jersey Airport, real life is a little different – it does not always follow the path predicted by a scriptwriter or director. Of late, we have been reading about your opinions and statements on matters beyond the celluloid world. Nothing is wrong in it. You live in a free, democratic country and are entirely entitled to your opinion. But as a
common man and an army officer and a polo player, also from the same soil, I
think I have the right too to raise a few points that may not conform to
your views of the real world.
I hope you will read it out.
When recently, the Pakistani players were not selected for the IPL, it was
almost predictable that NDTV, the award-winning, mouthpiece of our Indian
liberal media select you for your views and you certified that “It
(Pakistan) is a great neighbour to have. We (India and Pakistan) are great
neighbours. They are good neighbours.”
I Col ajay ahlawat, have a few words to say about those statements.
One may recall your effort to clarify the Pakistani team captain, Shoaib
Malik’s apology to the Muslims, living all over the world, for failing to
win the final T20 match against India, likely much to the embarrassment of a
lot of Indian Muslims, as expressed by Shamin Bano, mother of the man of the
match, Irfan Pathan. What was more embarrassing was your effort to try to
defend Shoaib in a subsequent interview, “I don”t think he meant to
segregate Muslims and Christians and Hindus and say this was a match between
Islam and Hinduism. I don”t think that…”

I doubt whether Shoaib talked to you personally about his thought process at
that time. You did not really have to respond for somebody else but perhaps
you could not resist the temptation to show your brotherhood and solidarity.

This reminds us again of Dr Ambedkar’s observation that, *”The brotherhood
of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of
Muslims for Muslims only.”*
Partition of India was what Pakistan wanted and got. It was painful to
millions but many more millions in present India have been spared. Since
then Pakistan has offered us only hatred. It has imposed on us three major
wars, the *Kargil insurgency*, the *Kashmir conflict*, the series of *serial
blasts*, the routine *violation of border ceasefires*, attacks on the
*Parliament
House* and the recent *Mumbai 26/11 attack*.

Did you have these in mind when you talked about them being good neighbours?

In another interview you had tried to explain the concept of Islamic Jihad.
*”I think one needs to understand the meaning of jihad .. I’ve understood
the essence that jihad is not about killing other people (correct me if I am
wrong); jihad is about killing the badness in you**.” *
I have personally met you on a number of occassions on the polo field and at
common friends houses,May be you understand jihad better and deeper than the
superficial meaning of what we, the rest of the mortal mankind, overburdened
and terrorized by the inter-religious, intra-religious and sectarian
violence that is plaguing the world in the name of Islam today, do. For we,
the less educated, cannot really make a difference between Jihad and Qatl,
between Jihad by heart / soul, Jihad by pen and Jihad by sword or between
lesser and greater jihad.
I wonder, whatever its meaning may be, does it minimize the significance of
the mindless killings that we see today in the name of Islam, across
borders, all over the world? Does it change the nature of the killers
whether you call them *holy warriors, mujahidins, fedayeens or plane suicide
bombers?*
I agree with you that terrorism has no religion. But hopefully you will also
agree with the people who perceive that most terrorist in the world today
happen to believe in the scriptures of Islam. They actually believe that
they themselves are the true Islamists.
The so called “moderate” Islamist, perhaps does not want to contradict them
or may be does not dare to speak out against them. You have probably not
forgotten the FIR against you for listing Prophet Mohammed as one of the
most unimpressive personalities in history, the threats from which you had
to skillfully wriggle out. Others who are not so fortunate, famous or
flexible are suffering lifetime, as *Tasleema Nasreen* or *Salman
Rushdie*would testify. For blasphemy in Islam is punishable with
death, even for a
believer.
Do I have to spell out the fate if it is a non-believer?
It is due to the inherent intolerance and exclusivity of Islam itself
despite your effort to convince us that there is an Islam from Allah and
very unfortunately, there is an Islam from the Mullahs.
Here is an historical insight from writer Irfan Hussain, *”The Muslim heroes
who figure larger than life in our history books committed some dreadful
crimes..all have blood-stained hands that the passage of years has not
cleansed. Indeed, the presence of Muslim historians on their various
campaigns has ensured that the memory of their deeds will live long after
they were buried…Seen through Hindu eyes, the Muslim invasion of their
homeland was an unmitigated disaster.” *

So why should the “non-believers” care to accept them? Why should the
majority of Indians like to welcome back such disasters again?
Since partition, India has come a long way in progress and development to
her current status and is projected as an economic superpower in coming
decades while Pakistan is perceived as a failed state on the verge of
disintegration.
What does India have to gain by offering neighbourly friendship to such a
hostile and failed state? *
India* has *never been an invader* and is not in conflict of any other
Muslim country. None of the wars and conflicts with Pakistan was instigated
by India. In the current geopolitical situation, one can argue for the
Muslim worlds grudge and anger against Israel or the west and USA but one
fail to fathom why India should also be at the receiving end and why Indians
should be the second largest group of people to die from terrorists attacks.
Indian majorities do not have anything to do with the Danish cartoon or the
death of Saddam Hussain; so why should they suffer from Islamic havoc on
those occasions.
In almost all occasions of terrorism, questions are raised about possible
role of Pakistan, its terror bases and its terrorist organizations, as
either directly or indirectly involved. Be it state sponsored (as recently
admitted by President Zardari) or by non-state actors, Pakistan or Pakistani
born are prime suspect in terrorist activities all over the world. The ISI
has been accused of playing a role in *major terrorist attacks including
9/11 in the USA, terrorism in Kashmir, Mumbai Train Bombings, London
Bombings, Indian Parliament Attack, Varanasi bombings, Hyderabad bombings,
Mumbai terror attacks or the attack on the Indian embassy in Kabul. *
Do you believe these are marks of a good neighbour? Then what is the reason
for your preaching of love towards Pakistan?
Perhaps, as you said, because it is your ancestor’s homeland, you have a
soft feeling for Pakistan and cannot see the difference. On the eve of
accepting an honorary doctorate from a British university, we heard you say,
*”I really believe we are the same ..when you come away from India or
Pakistan you realize there is no Indian or Pakistani were all together. We
are – culturally, as human beings, as friends” *
Which Pakistanis are you referring to?
The Pakistanis belonging to the land, admonished as the epicenter of global
terrorism, not just by India or USA but even by its friendly allies like
Iran or China.
Or is it the self-created, Talibanic Pakistan, who still imposes Jijya on
the non believers or finds pleasure in blowing up girl’s schools..?
Are you talking about it’s President class like the current Mr. Zardari,
vowed to wage a 1,000-year war with India or the late Mrs. Bhutto who
started Jihad in Kashmiri that lead to the exodus of Hindu minorities from
the Muslim majority state of India, as refugees in their own country?
Are you referring to Pakistanis loyal to the ISI and the military who train
their soldiers with only one objective, i.e. to fight Hindu India?
If your mind is concerned about the faceless mass of Pakistanis, does it
also include the dwindling minorities? Or are you just concerned about the
celebrities and the social elites?
It is true Mr. Khan, that we belong to the same human species but it is hard
to stretch the similarities much further between “us” and “them”.
We from the same original land of *Bharat* but we want to keep her intact,
and they want to break it into thousand pieces.
Our ancestors happen to be the same. We acknowledge and adore the heritage
but they abhor and decimate whoever is available in an attempt to wipe out
the link.
We are culturally the same. We have created the culture over centuries what
they dream to destroy in moments.
Our’s is a *10,000 year old civilization*, theirs is a *62 years old country
* undoing whole human civilization.
We extend our hands repeatedly to promote friendship and amity; they give us
ISI, Lashkar, Harkat, Kashmir, Kargil and 26/11 in exchange.
Do you think that the Indians nationals or my coursemates who died in all
the above wars, the Indian soldiers who lost their lives in cross-border
ceasefire violations or the Indian civilians who are killed by the ISI
trained Islamic terrorists and their affiliates, in all those serial blasts,
all over the country, willfully sacrificed their lives as a friendly
neighbourhood gesture?
Can you face the families of the victims of *Chhatrapati Shivaji
Terminus*or the martyrs of the
*Kargil war* and try to explain to them that *”They are good neighbours. Let
us love each other.” *
Can you explain why the two gunmen at Cama hospital, during the Mumbai
carnage, asked the man who gave them water, what his religion was, and shot
him dead when he said he was a Hindu?
If you cannot, then perhaps you understand why the majority of India does
not consider Pakistan as a good neighbour to have.
Perhaps you believe that the peaceful religious co-existence that you
created in your home (and we appreciate that) can be extended to the large
world outside. As you rightly said, we Indians trust and do accept everybody
but what you did fail to mention was that it is the Indic tradition,
essentially coming out of its pre-Islamic Hindu ethos.
If you think otherwise, show us a single Islamic country where the
non-believers enjoy the same equality as the believers. Since partition, the
Hindus left over in Pakistan and Bangladesh has suffered terribly. Strictly
Islamic countries, like Saudi Arabia, do not allow any other religions to
exist. Hindus working in the Gulf countries are not allowed to practice
their religion in public. Saudi Arabia insists that India sends only a
Muslim ambassador. Hindu Muslim unity by and large has generally been a
matter of Hindus trying to please or accommodate Muslims. One cannot forget
when Vajpayee was extending his hand for peace, Musharraf was planning the
Kargil insurgency.
Let me remind you, your own statement *”I am a Muslim in a country called
India .We’ve never been made to feel this is a Hindu country.” *
Can you find me a Hindu in Pakistan who can reciprocate that sentiment?
Some years ago, another Mr. Khan, first name Feroze, from your fraternity
was banned from entering Pakistan for saying, *”India is secular unlike
Pakistan”. *
That is the basic difference of the land of “Hindu” India from the Islamic
“pure land” of Pakistan.  So please do not ask us to love Pakistan.
Please do not lump the people of India and Pakistan together. We Indians are
proud to preserve our separate identity..
And please do not insult the land that gave you your life, name and fame, by
claiming that her worst enemy, who wants to break her into 1000 pieces, is a
great neighbour.
Otherwise it would be sad if somebody accuses you of putting your religion
ahead of your country.
Please give it a thought.
Regards,

45 Responses to “Open Letter To Mr. Shah Rukh Khan”

  1. Jayant Pant says:

    Thank you for calling spade a spade.

    My stomach churns everytime I see this guy getting all the attention from media, government and eunuch politicians, “P-secs” and so called “educated” – basically convent schooled desis.

    Dear Mr.Ahlawat,
    I salute your courage for writing this.

    Jayant

  2. Devendra says:

    Awesome job Colonel, a tight slap on Pseudo-Secular Sharukh Khan and his liberal media.

  3. Vivek says:

    Hello Colonel:

    Awesome writing, I wish this article is read by each and everyone person of this country, irrespective of there religion, and feel what kind of pain we are going through being an INDIAN.

    Its a very brave hearted open letter, which i have seen in the recent times.

    Kudos to your Sir.

  4. Ravindra says:

    wow.. fantastic………. I cant express & explain my felings….

    Thanks to Mr.Co.Ajay & Pratap sir

  5. from_sj says:

    Dear Mr. Ahlawat,

    Please post the reply if you get any from Mr. Khan. I am curious to see the response. No matter what the religion is if a person is citizen of India should be loyal to India.
    otherwise, they are called “Namak Haraam”
    “jis thali me khaya, usi me ched kiya”
    Thanks
    from_sj(concerned Indian)

  6. shruthi says:

    kudos to mr.colonel ajay ahlawat…………..fantastic letter

  7. poornima says:

    Its ridiculous, that Mr Khan’s wife is a Hindu , and as he says he respects both the religion equally, but after all these he still prioritises HIS RELIGION AND ITS FOLLOWERS. Mr Khan we Hindus belong to a culture where even if our enemies come to our door step for help we give them a helping and that is what we have been thought by our elders, our epics, our Holy book and hence, we are doing all these years , now, people like u have bent upon changing us, dont worry our foundation is very very strong

  8. SHRIGANESH A DAMLE says:

    Good article. Real villans of this country are media. Who supports Shah Rukh kind thoughts.
    They are more worried about muslims, their ‘problems'(???) than terrorism.

  9. Bharath says:

    Thanks Mr Ahlawat…indeed an eye-opener.

    I hate him anyway.

    Jai Hind..

  10. keerthi says:

    Kudos to Mr. AHLAWAT, for this open letter.

    Mr.Khan go to any other country on earth and do the same. In many countries, they would kill you in public without any second thought. Its only in India you are let free. and you are still breathing normally. Hope you understand that fact.

    Oh god, why did you take our KFI hero Vishnuvardhan so early? Don’t you see any other people?

    Jai Hind.

  11. Dr.N.H.Krishna says:

    Mr.Shah rukh khan(prior i would have adressed u my favourite most SRK next to Dr.Rajkumar!),
    This day I am a renowned PULMONOLOGIST.I did my M.B.B.S. from Davangere,Karnataka with admission year 1992.If we travel back in time a little distance,i remember that after DEEWANA & CHAMATHKAR,it was a dream flow for u! BAZIGAR,DARR,KABHIE HAAN KABHIE NAA!!! Oh i became faint upon u!U know i started acting like u mimicking ur voice so good that i even used to mimick that how would u talk in Kannada too!In an event named MOCK PRESS I always was picking the 1st prize playing ur act in college day events!
    But I was a laughing stock in my college especially after ur ANJAAM!They all were laughing at me that SRK is a type casted actor,he can’t play any other role than a psycho lover & he is not even the little finger’s nail dust of AMITHAB BACHHAN!
    Very very funnily most of my muslim college mates,almost all were great fan of AMITHAB & used to neglect u!This stands a vital ex even today that only Hindus never made AMITHAB the super star & only Muslims never made a super star!
    But then u answered my prayers! U never remained type casted to a negative role,u started acting versatile like Dr.RAJ KUMAR,AMITHAB BACCHAN & KAMAL HASSAN! U answered all my critics by many movies.one finest world stood ex is DDLJ!Then u never looked back & need not too as u were a God created human to make & break records in acting!
    Here let me to clear a point to u very straight.I have been an AMITHAB fan always even before u & even this date.But I admired u still!Because we Indians r not pocessed with a pre occupied thought,that loving u is hating someone else!Till this date one of my Indian classmate in abroad these days is a die hard fan of AMITHABH & DR.RAJKUMAR.Initially we always to fight about ur caliber!Now thank God he doesn’t scold u!By mere co incidence he is a MUSLIM!
    Had me r him been regional fans alone.let me kindly tell u there is no one like DR.RAJKUMAR in the entire world in film industry!He is the only man to fetch both BEST ACTOR & BEST SINGER NATIONAL AWARD MANY TIMES!
    BUT!BUT!BUT!
    We INDIANS can only like,people without border of state,religion or country!
    Being a KANNADIGA although i know DRAVID is great,i vote TENDULKAR to be a legend & VIVIAN RICHARDS the best all rounder i ever saw!
    I was the happiest when i saw a movement where u were compared parallel to AMITHABH even while he was living!
    U acted in SWADESH,it was a such an inspiring movie!But bad luck it became a flop.I never neglected ur caliber of acting still although i had seen the same movie made over 4 decades ago!surpraised!!same movie concept was screened in KANNADA in BANGARADA MANUSHYA & it had run for 3 & half years in BENGALURU in theatres!The biggest hit till this date in Karnataka!
    u acted in CHAK DE INDIA made us all to think back about hockey over cricket & thanks a million to that!
    My sincere hats off to u that u left ur wife to follow her religion & name even after getting married to u.i even respect your broad mindedness.
    NOW KINDLY ANSWER TO A QUESTION OF MINE?
    The KING KHAN image given to u was by all INDIANS which contains 85% HINDU POPULATION!We all called u KING KHAN,should u still tell us that MY NAME IS KHAN?What if your body was not named as KHAN,even KOWL or CHRISTOFER we would not have valued ur talent of acting?
    HOW CAN U USE YOUR BUILTED IMAGE BY ALL INDIANS CONTRIBUTION,TO ACT AS AN AMBASSADOR OF A PERTICULAR RELIGION!
    Well still tears come out that the 1st letter I am typing to u is like this!
    AS YOUR EARLIEST,LONGEST & BIGGEST FAN,I KINDLY REQUEST U ONE THING.
    PLEASE PLEASE CALL A PRESS MEET & KINDLY ASK SORRY TO US YOUR FANS,NOT FOR YOUR CRITICS!
    I am sure my SRK will do it & will save fans like me to answer to your critics day & night for being your fan!
    God bless u always. waiting for ur reply

  12. Sharath says:

    Great article …….
    People .. Talk Bullshit .. With actually understanding the Sentiments of the people at the receiving.
    . I have seen a lot soldiers from my place lose thier life .. due to bloody Pakistanis .

    .. I salute you sir 🙂

  13. Sharath says:

    Wonderful ..
    .Coming from a soldiers family . I understand ur sentiment.

    SRK is a bloody . Publicity sucker

  14. ULLEKH HEGDE says:

    Awesome article…opens the curtain and shows the real face of these pseudo-secular idiots!!! Our media has become our no. 1 enemy. A fight has to begun against these people who just brain wash people and show all false things…

  15. hari krishna says:

    first of all i would like to congratulate Col. Ajay Ahlawat. This indian muslims are given enough indepndence and priority. Although they know pakistan is an utterly waste and terror country, they support pakistan only.

    Somebody told in this forum that , Mr. Rajkumar is a great actor. How funny. First of all he doesn’t have acting skills , morover a big nose is a mere obstruction.
    He is not at all comparable to our all time greats like NTR,ANRand SVR.

    Also lets get rid of pakistan from the globe.

  16. Sapan says:

    ULLEKH HEGDE you are correct. nowaday media had come no 1 enemy. They dont think which is correct.. they want there channel publicity. Thats it.

    Dear Mr. AJAY AHLAWAT .
    I really salute u sir.
    Thanks for awesome artical.

  17. Pavan Kumar says:

    Sir its fantastic letter. Hats of you dear Ahlawat teaching a lesson to a blind actor one who always wants to be in headlines everyday.

  18. Abdul says:

    hello sir…
    your letter is superb… its like tight slap on mr shah rukh khan. and yes pakistan is
    NOT Diserve to be called as ” Good neighbour country”.

  19. Atul says:

    Great Article Sir …….Hats Off to you

    In this Bised Media World where you are like a ray of hope for Ordinary people like me …

  20. Raviji says:

    Dear Col. Ajay Ahlawat,

    I really appreciate your open letter to Mr. Khan and i also appreciate the comments by the people for you and for Mr. Khan. By now, Mr. Khan mush have understood that we indian don’t act or judge people by their religion but by their behavior. Still the main accuse of 26/11 attack AJMAL is alive and we have spent crores of rupees on him. Mr. Khan you live in india and whatever you are because of INDIAN, so you should first support india then other country.

    Pakistanis are alwasy suckers and pakistan should not exist on globe.

  21. Mukund says:

    How can we make this letter to reach SRK OR atleast media like NDDTV

  22. Hiten Patel says:

    well, strong letter i’d say…
    atmost respect to all Indians, but I m on SRK’s side in this argument…!
    I am frm Mumbai, a Hindu, and I have narrowly escaped the serial train blasts of 2006, but I still seek peace n friendship…

    I am not a very good speaker and cannot express my thoughts as clearly as respectable Col. Alhawat, but its my individual perception that I seek friendship and initiate to end hatred… and I don’t mean to ask any other Indian to start to forgive n forget… if u wanna hate, its your perception and your choice, and I respect that…. I want love and peace n its my perception and my choice.

    my definition of Peace does not mean forgetting all the terror attacks on the country… the right culprit, when caught should NEVER BE SPARED and should be sentenced to most severe punishment by law. (some govt. or group supposedly protecting the right culprit from trial is altogether different argument). I find many other faceless common men in the cities of lahore or karachi or Islamabad, who are just like me on a street of Mumbai, and I don’t want to hate them for what the ISI or Lashkar groups are doing.

    I totally respect all the brave soldiers guarding the country and standing between the enemies and me so that I cud breathe freely and write my thoughts inside a safe India. I totally weep for the families who have lost someone in a terror attack..
    but if I have to answer whether peace or war, love or hatred can end this suffering, I wud stand for peace n love… yea, we (India) are a nuclear power and like soo many Indians saying in soo many forums, 2 bombs and Pak disappears from the world map… true that, but do we really want to believe it is gonna end at that? even Mighty Emperor Ashoka realized that killing was not gonna work, n he adopted the path of peace, where he influenced many more people and cultures than he did by killing…

    I am not saying, maintain status quo and keep getting slaughtered by these terrorists… I m as much agitated and frustrated with each new terror strike… I share every other Indian’s feeling of helplessness… there have been soo many terror strikes in Pak cities where common ppl like us have died…. i also empathize their feeling of helplessness… those common ppl wud feel just like how we (Indians) feel when a terrorist strikes our city.

    what is a terrorist?? any person/group who terrorizes or frightens others.
    with this definition, even those hindu extremists within India are terrorists who beat up gals clubbing in B’lore/H’bad, or those who wud burn the gift shops in Mumbai that sells valentine gifts… these groups are spreading terror!!! do we want them to kill some fixed number of ppl after which we can classify them as terrorists? my point here is, terrorists can be everywhere and not restricted to any country… I totally support the idea of violence and bomb a terrorist group and wipe them off the face of the earth, but i just don’t support the idea of randomly bombing a country.

    While some narrow minded ppl in India have their borders of love restricted only to Mumbaikars (or Marathis), a majority of other Indians have their border of love spanning across the entire Republic of India (which is really awesome!).
    I am just taking one step further by breaking the political borders and creating my own border between terrorist across the world and oppressed across the world, so my border of love is for every human that is oppressed by terrorism.

    I am sorry if I hurt someones sentiments with my thoughts, but again, it is just my belief and I want to stand by it.

  23. santhosh says:

    Hats of COLONEL AJAY AHLAWAT!!!!! i completely agree with u’r article !!!!! its not just SRK awho’s suffering from “community soft corner syndrome” also aamir khan, emraan hashmi, saif ali khan, shabhana azmi etc who av +ve made statements regarding pakistan and islam !!!!! unfortunately even our media is sick of TRPs!!!! so called our politicians r same

  24. Sushma says:

    Hello Ajay,

    Thankyou for writing !!!

    very well expressed. I think Mr.Shahrukh Khan should give a tought.

    regards,
    sushma

  25. AN INDIAN WOMENS thought says:

    COLONEL AJAY AHLAWAT!!!!! I agree to your thoughts….SRK should understand the sentiments of we INDIANS…… SRK A *************

  26. ManjuNathan says:

    That is a true Indian’s feeling…
    So as I do

    JAI HIND!!!

    Let this letter each all Indians

  27. Kavi says:

    Awesome job Colonel…. hats off to you…. Nothing gonna affect this Guy, its like wrestling with a pig in mud. After a while you realize that while you are getting dirty, the pig is actually enjoying it. Most people are only alive because it is illegal to shoot them. At least in GREAT INDIA. One we are feeding in the Jail for the Mumbai Blast…..

  28. RITU(IT PROFESSIONAL) says:

    Respected COLONEL AJAY AHLAWAT

    Even if you have tried to put such a great truth-revealing article,our INDIAN Leaders are still agreeging to make friendship with PAKISTAN.

    I strongly agree to the comments made by you against Mr SHAHRUK KHAN.Even thought he is a great actor but he failed to become a true INDIAN…….
    WHY CANT YOU MAKE A MOVIE SAYING “I M INDIAN”??????
    and WHY “MY NAME IS KHAN”????

    i beleive all INDIAN MUSLIMS are not the same.ASK A MEMBER OF AN INDIAN FAMILY WHO HAS LOST HIS SON,HUSBAND OR FATHER IN A TERROR ATTACK BY PAKISTAN???THEY ARE THE REAL SUFFERERS!!
    WE WILL FORGET THESE INCIDENTS IN A MONTH OR SO AND AGAIN RECALL IT WHEN ITS ANNIVERSARY COMES,BUT WHAT ABOUT THOSE WHOSUFFER EACH AND EVERY DAY REMEMBERING THE INCIDENT.ITS REALLY PATHETIC FOR THEM.

    I AM AGAINST ALL THOSE WHO FEEL WE SHOULD DO FRIENSHIP WITH PAKISTAN.

    HOW MANY TIMES WE WILL GIVE THEM A CHANCE?????I M 22YEARS OLD,AND AS FAR AS I KNOW OUR GENERATION ALSO BELIEVES THAT PAKISTAN IS THE REAL CAUSE OF TERRORISM……………

    PRESIDENT MANMOHAN SINGH SHOULD PUT FORWARD STRICT RULES AGAINST ALL PAKISTANIS AND SHOULD BAN EACH AND EVERY CONTACT WITH THEM.

    WHEATHER IT IS OSAMA BIN LADEN OR PARVEZ MUSSHAREF,BOTH HAVE ESCAPED FROM COPS…..

    SHAHRUK KHAN….CAN YOU MAKE A MOVIE ON THIS????MY NAME IS KHAN WAS ONLY FOR MUSLIMS…BUT

    “I BELIEVE ALL INDIAN WANT YOU TO MAKE NEXT MOVIE AGAINST THE TERRORISM TO INDIA”

    SHAHRUK KHAN PLZZZ EXPLAIN IS IT FEASIBLE TO MAKE FRIENSHIP WITH PAKISTAN NOW???????????????????????/

    PAKISTAN – A state where terrorism is TEACHED,PREACHED and SUSTAINED….

  29. Kavi says:

    Awesome job Colonel…. hats off to you…. Nothing gonna affect this Guy, its like wrestling with a pig in mud. After a while you realize that while you are getting dirty, the pig is actually enjoying it. Most people are only alive because it is illegal to shoot them.

  30. bhavesh ray says:

    wow..,well said sir..,
    thanks for revealing such a wonderfull fact which every one should kno..

  31. Nitin Kumar says:

    Bullshit article. Do you remember the welcome that Team india got while they last visited Pakistan? Why are you linking the misdeeds of Pakistan to SRK ? NDTV is a secular media, and I love it. Probably it did not praise the Idi Amin of India, Narendra Modi as national hero. thats why you hate NDTV.

    It is the narrow mentality IPL commissionor and cunning people like you made to ommit pakistani Players.

    Nitin Kumar, NY, USA.

  32. kartika says:

    nice work

    Media always biased
    Congress and SRk bought media
    They throw money on this money dance on they tunes misguide Indians
    ask SRK to make movie on Kashmir Pandits also.

    Just media made & still keep him alive making news otherwise may before 5 years he can be vanish from Bollywood .

  33. Arun (country comes First, Not religion) says:

    Dear Col Ajay ahlawat,

    Hats off to you for your open letter to SRK,
    It represents voice of all True Indians irrespective of religion, border.
    Anyone who says Pakistan is good neighbour should be made answerable to the family members of those who have lost lives in fighting against terrorists.
    and Shoab malik is an idiot to apologize for whole muslim community, and Mr. khan tried to show the same by defending him.

    IN INDIA LOVE FOR MOTHERLAND IS PATRIOTISM, BUT FOR PAKISTAN HATING INDIA IS PATRIOTISM.

    THEY ARE SEEDING TERRORISM THROUGH THE TEXT BOOKS FROM TENDER AGE.
    THEY COMPLETELY PREACH WRONG HISTORY, WE HAVE NEVER BEEN TAUGHT TO HATE PAKISTAN IN OUR SCHOOLS, THE FACTS AND THE WAY PAKISTAN BEHAVES ITSELF MAKES US TO HATE PAKISTAN,
    THEN HOW CAN A TRUE INDIAN SAY PAKISTAN AS A GOOD NEIGHBOUR….??

  34. Nachiket says:

    @Nithin kumar,

    It seems like your totally ignorant or dumbest guy on earth. How can you call NDTV a secular media ? It is more like congress pro media just like Fox news of republicans in USA. So get your facts right before you bark .

  35. Jay says:

    Great Article Ajay

    Whist SRK may have billions of fans (they will have an IQ of 10 because he is a fiction rather than a fact), but I am sure he will have the same amount of “HATE” fans, and me being one of them, he is just another human being, with the same faults as the next person, but for fans who treat him like a king, emphasises the fact that their IQ or intelligence level must be ZERO.

    If he feels Pakistan are good neighbours, why does he not go and live there, or is he scared of being blown up by the good neighbours. My 50 years of experience with Pakistanis narrows down to one fact “the only good pakistani is a dead one”, and as “INCEST” is their forte, we will have less disfigured humans (pakistanis) in the world.

    SRK, do not piss on the country that has given you fame and fortune (undeserved), and fans who think he is the KING need mental help, great actors are humble and intelligent people like Amitabh and Hrithik. You are just a pretender, ugly and your nose needs plastic surgery, unless you want to look like “pinnochio”.

    The world should realise that there are only one type of fanatics and these sre the muslims, with no history, lost tribe and culture and these flaws have made them what they are, and never will they be friends or well wishers of India and who cares, certainly not India or any indians, India needs to (it should have done in the first war) wipe them out of the Atlas permanently and Nitin Kumar from USA, why dont you change to a muslim and get your thing chopped, because you dont need it and donate it to the animal kingdom, and well said NACHIKET.

  36. Bharath Kumar S M says:

    KUDOS COL Sir… your letter should shut this guys bloody mouth.

    Thanks a TON Pratap for posting this letter in your forum. I really like your articles on VK.

    @Nitin (USA) : you do not have any rights to talk about India or Indians. You are a DUMB Selfish person settled in US who doesnt respect his Motherland or Religion.

  37. santhosh says:

    hi sir plz mail to my id

  38. THANKS TO ONE AND ALL FOR YOUR COMMENTS- MUCH APPERICIATED . LIKES OR DISLIKES NEGATIVE OR POSITIVE . I RESPECT EACH ONES VIEWS AND COMMENTS AND SALUTE YOU FOR READING IT AND WRITING BACK.

    WARM REGARDS
    ALLY

  39. tiger badsara says:

    deal colonel,
    we r proud to hav army officers like u in indian army who can challenge any one if found playing with system and country. i hav seen millions comments on sharukhs face book and twiter people r crazy for these celebraties…………… not realizing why is he so great………… sir true hero and celebraty is colonel mahindra singh dhoni who acts as good as sharukh see his adds, he devotes his free time with army soldiers without media, who volunteerly joind army to serve soldiers and a true human being but never sold his personal life to media. we salute both col ahalawat and col dhoni

  40. it gud job done prathap sir

  41. Dear friends,

    “Sometimes it is better to let go in peace than hold on in pain.”

    I INFORM YOU ALL WITH A HEAVY HEART THAT MAJOR SURINDER BADSARA-OF THE ELITE 4 PARA COMMANDOS – WHOSE COMMENT IS POSTED ON 12 NOV 2011 ON THIS PLATFORM , PASSED AWAY IN DELHI ON 22ND JUNE 2012.

    Great achievement is usually born of great sacrifice, and is never the result of selfishness.

    HE WAS A BATTLE CASUALTY IN JAMMU AND KASHMIR AND LAID HIS LIFE PROTECTING US ALL. HE WAS A HIGHLY DECORATED SOLDIER AND HAD BEEN GIVEN REWARDS BY THE ARMY FOR HIS BRAVERY ON A NUMBER OF OCCASIONS.

    HIS WIFE IS AN ARMY OFFICER TOO AND CONTINUES TO SERVE IN THE SAME REGION- PROTECTING THE MOTHERLAND AND ENSURING THAT WE ALL SLEEP PEACEFULLY. YOUR PRAYERS FOR THE DEPARTED SOUL WILL BE GREATLY APPRECIATED.

    THIS IS WHAT I HAVE ALWAYS MEANT WHEN I WROTE THE ABOVE ARTICLE THAT WE RECEIVE A BODY BAG EVERY DAY FROM THE TROUBLED AREAS. EVERYDAY SOMEONE’S SON-BROTHER-FATHER-HUSBAND LAYS DOWN HIS LIFE. EVERYDAY.

    A VISIT TO THE R AND R ARMY HOSPITAL, DELHI ICU WARD WILL MAKE YOU UNDERSTAND THE PAIN AND LOSS. I STILL REMEMBER THAT WHOEVER WENT WITH ME TO VISIT HIM IN THE ICU – CIVILIANS ,POLICEMEN,JUDGES, INDUSTRIALISTS,BUSINESSMEN- COULD NOT CONTROL THEIR GRIEF AND PAIN AND CRIED OPENLY AND WERE SHOCKED.THERE HE WAS LYING IN THE ICU WITH A SMILE AND NO REGRETS. HIS FATHER AN EX ARMY MAN WAS THERE TOO READY TO SEND HIS YOUNGER SON TO THE ARMY. HIS COMMANDING OFFICER A TOP COMMANDO ON THE INDIAN ARMY WAS MOVED TOO AND SAID- ” I HAVE NEVER SEEN SOMEONE SO HAPPY BRAVE AND DEDICATED”FOR HIS CREMATION IN A SMALL VILLAGE NEAR PILLANI,RAJASTHAN- ALL THE VILLAGES HAD CLOSED THEIR SHOPS IN RESPECTS AND THE CROWDS WHO HAD COME THERE TOO PAY THEIR RESPECTS WERE BEYOND BELIEF. I FEEL HE WAS THE RICHEST MAN THAT -A AND IT WAS PROVED THAT DAY. I HOPE ALL OF US CAN HAVE SUCH A SEND OFF. THAT’S THE TRUE RICHNESS. HE HAD MADE HIS FRIENDS, FAMILY, VILLAGE, STATE, AND COUNTRY ALL PROUD.

    HIS FAMILY WILL GET A FEW LAC RUPEES AND WILL SOON BE FORGOTTEN BY US ALL. BUT EACH MEMBER OF HIS FAMILY WILL CARRY THIS PAIN FOR EVER DEEP IN THEIR HEARTS TILL THEIR GRAVES.

    AN AMERICAN SOLDIER WHEN HE GOES INTO SUCH DANGEROUS AREAS IS INSURED FOR ONE MILLION USD. THE INDIAN ARMY OFFICERS/JAWANS ARE MADE TO COMPULSORILY PAY 2400 RS EACH MONTH BUT WHAT THEY GET AFTER DEATH IS A FEW LAC RUPEES. IT’S THE BIGGEST SCAM BEING CARRIED OUT BY THE INSURANCE COMPANIES AND NO ONE HAS HAD THE GUTS TO STAND UPTO IT.

    “DO NOT CRY FOR THE ONE WHO HAS LEFT BUT FOR THE ONES WHO LIVE” – I agree for they carry the burden of grief and memories.

    ITS SCARY BECAUSE THE WAY ITS GOING WE ALREADY HAVE 16000 OFFRS SHORT IN THE ARMY AND ITS JUST A MATTER OF TIME WHEN WE ARE DOWN TO SERIOUS SHORTAGE. UNTIL AND UNLESS WE DO NOT MAKE IT WORTHWHILE FOR THE ONES WHO LAY DOWN THEIR LIVES TO MAKE THE SUPREME SACRIFICE WHO WILL BE THERE TO DO SO.

    ITS SAD BUT A FACT THAT SUPREME SACRIFICE WILL CONTINUE TO BE REQUIRED AND THE LEAST WE ALL CAN DO IS TO ENSURE THAT THE ONE WHO IS DOING IT IS – REST ASSURED THAT HIS NEAR ONES ARE LOOKED AFTER VERY WELL. ALL SUPPORT/ RESPECT/ GOOD KIND WORDS/MEDALS/AWARDS BOILS DOWN TO MONEY AT THE END OF THE DAY. WE CAN NEVER REPAY THE DEBT OF THIS SACRIFICE BUT IF WE CAN MAKE SURE THAT THEY LIVE COMFORTABLY ATLEAST – IT’S THE GREATEST SERVICE WE CAN DO TO THE BRAVES.

    I KNOW MAJOR BADASRA DIED FIGHTING FOR OUR MOTHERLAND AND HIS WISH WAS TO BUY A PLOT IN GURGAON FOR HIS FAMILY. IMAGINE AN OFFICER WHO WAS 32 YRS OLD AND TODAY HAS NOT A SINGLE HOME OR PROPERTY OF HIS OWN. IMAGINE WHAT HAPPENS TO THE JAWANS. I TALK ABOUT BADSARA BUT THERE IS A BADSARA DYING EVERY DAY- E V E R Y D A Y. COME TO THE HOSP AND SEE IT FOR YOURSELF .

    I personally also have to take part blame as I have trained many officers like him and I failed if i could not teach him to survive. We don’t teach our boys to lay down their lives for our motherland but to take the enemies life for his motherland. The professional arena always demands intense commitment. One has to be a high achiever; nobody can deny that, I will still continue to work on my projects without letting up and am not ready to brook any interference. Though welcome suggestions and criticism. I set very high standards not just for my subordinates but also for myself. This uncompromising attitude though, alienates my supporters sometimes, but being frank is always better than being falsely sweet coz by being frank in life, we may get lot of true enemies but surely no untrue friends.

    WITH A HEAVY HEART AND GREAT ADMIRATION FOR DEAREST BADSARA AND PRAYERS FOR HIS FAMILY AND FRIENDS, I LEAVE YOU WITH THINGS TO PONDER UPON. lets not allow these supreme sacrifice go waste. lets tell stories of such valor to our children and instill respect for such humans.grateful .

    WISHES
    ALLY

  42. Sandeep Kharvi says:

    Dear Ajay,

    good work…. but you have mentioned everything except one most important thing..
    Anil Sharma, the popular bollywood director once offered him a role for anti-pak movie but he declined the offer.. let it be.. we have no issues… after some time he produced movie called ”mein hoon naa”…. that movie was soo unrealistic that nobody can imagine that…. Acc to his view “Indian” can be a terrorist.. (particularly army officer) but “pakistani”” can never be a terrorist.. and he has insulted our beloved army people.. if you have not watched that movie, i request please watch and write article on that…. I’m expecting a article either from ur side or Pratap……….

  43. Ranjit Lamba Ex CAVALIER says:

    Dear Col Ally,

    Happy to read your views on inclination of Mr SRK towards his section. Indeed, it is pathetic that he is still seeing our 65 years old enemy as a good neighbour. How can
    he be a good neighbour by taking away even the heads of our soldiers. I salute you, as ever in the `Cavalier’ Times, for writing this couragious blog. Regards.

  44. lovely lamp says:

    hello sir,an excellent job done…….mr.srk doesn’t know that the fame he has got is, in india our mother land,else for his senseless acting in public like this he would never get such respect…this letter is an eye opener and people should know the truth and act sensibly………

  45. Nayana says:

    hi,
    Very nice article sir. We respect our nation our neighbours also. Not the killers.